Bizbox Twitter:

    Yes, But Will Banks Finally Lend?

    By Bizbox

    0 The news of the Federal Reserve's latest contribution to the bailout--which includes a pledge to lend up to $200 billion, on favorable terms, against collateral that consists of securities backed by several types of troubled loans, including ones backed by the Small Business Administration--is being greeted as something that's finally going to loosen banks' lending gears. "Small businesses finally are getting their own little piece of the federal government’s ballooning bailout package," writes Independent Street in a typical offering.

    The post also quotes Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) offering praise on similar grounds: "This new focus by Treasury and the Fed should help inject some much needed economic life into Main Street and couldn’t come a day sooner."

    While we hope for the best, we're not exactly expecting it. We can't get this article from last Sunday's New York Times out of our head. It pointed out that despite receiving the initial injection of billions and billions in government capital on the implicit and explicit grounds that they were expected to lend it back out, the banks aren't offering much credit at all. Not that we didn't already know this: we did. But still, it's disheartening to read each time we have to read it.

    "Reports from institutional and individual borrowers across the country indicate this," writes the columnist Gretchen Morgensen. "Nervous lenders are demanding that even healthy loans be paid back. Banks and other financial institutions, meanwhile, are reducing exposures to borrowers and doing whatever they can to discourage the assumption of further debt."

    Morgensen doesn't blame the banks, exactly: they're just pursuing their own self-interest, which is another way of saying they're being good capitalists. It is for such reasons, rather, that government exists: to compel action that is not necessarily in economic players' self-interest but that is essential to the common good. Government does this constantly even when those whom it is compelling don't owe it anything. That it did not require (as opposed to encourage) specific behavior from banks that were the beneficiaries of hundreds of billions of dollars in government money is frankly kind of appalling. In other words, either promote a free market or don't--either let the banks die or bail them out. But if you're going to bail them out, at least make sure you get something in return!

    And so we're worried about this new step, because once again, there isn't really any compulsion. A bank could now put up its crappy asset-backed securities for Fed cash; and it could in turn lend that cash out to the small businesses that need it. Certainly in good times this would be a no-brainer: after all, in good times, lending out money is a prime way--maybe the prime way--banks make money. (That's what a bank is!) But these are not good times. And who's to say that banks, having borrowed that money, are going in turn to lend it out? Who's to say they're not going instead to take it and use it to buy smaller banks? Or increase dividends to hard-hit shareholders (and executives)? Nothing would stop them from doing that. Come to think of it, what's to stop them from simply not taking the Fed's money in the first place?

    Schumer may be praising this new step, which could, via three degrees of separation, increase lending to small businesses. But it's worth remembering that Schumer is also the one who proposed lending directly to small businesses, to the tune of somewhere in the neighborhood of $10 billion.

    If such a hypothetical program were to be instituted, there's not an x% chance that x% of the money would be lended to small businesses, as is the case with the Treasury Department's capital injections or with the Fed's new lending program. Rather, there would be a 100% chance that 100% of the allocated money woud be lended to small businesses. Too-big government? Government micromanagement? That ship has long since left the free-market harbor.

    Okay, okay. We hope it works--we hope the Fed's neutralizing of the toxicity of these assets ups lending to small businesses. But in case you couldn't tell, count us skeptical.

    Comments (0)

    November 26, 2008 12:25 PM

    Post a comment

    (Comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed.)

    (If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

    The Purpose Linked Organization

    by Alaina Love

    On Tuesday, July 14 earn how to harness your employees' passions so that they further your own.

    401(k) 401(k)s academics Advertising alternative energy American Express Americas Competitiveness Forum Android angel investing Anonymous Banker! Apple ARC Are You An Entrepreneur? athletes audits auto bailout Baby Boomers bailout Balance Banana Republic Banking Bankruptcy Banks Barack Obama bartering Bear Stearns Ben's Chili Bowl benefits Bill Cosby Bill Gates Biz Box Panel BizBooks BizBox BizEquity BJs black entrepreneurs Branding Brett Favre broadband business blogging Business Growth business incubators Business Planning Business Week Buzz Capital card-check Carl's Jr. cash flow CDFI Census China Chrome Chuck Schumer CIT Clients Cloud Computing cNet Collection Columbia University community banks Community Express Competition consumer spending convertible notes Costs coupons creative capitalism credit Credit credit cards credit score credit union currency Customer Service Day in the Life Debt Debt Repayment Digg Disaster Loans discounting Dodgeball Dun and Bradstreet Dunder-Mifflin e-commerce eBay eco-preneurship Elvis Email Employee Free Choice Act Employees Energy costs Entrepreneur.com Entrepreneurship estate tax Evan Bayh Facebook family business Fannie Mae FDIC Federal Reserve Financing Firefox Flex-time Flexibility Forbes fraud Fred's Freddie Mac Gap gelato George W. Bush Gizmodo Global Gmail Google Google Analytics Google Sites Government great rearranging green Green Bay Packers Greg Verdino Grom Happy New Year hats Health Care Highland Capital Hiring homestead exemption Housing bill HR ICBA identity theft iFund immigration incorporating Innovation innovation policy Internet Internet Explorer Introduction inventory optimization investment strategy iPhone iPod IRS iTunes Ivan Misner Jaiku Jerry Seinfeld Jill Lublin jobs John McCain Johnny Money joseph michelli JotSpot Karen G. Mills Kiva Late Payments leadership Legislation Lloyd Chapman Loan Repayment Loopt luxury M&M's M&M's Premium Magic Johnson Mamma Mia Management Market Value Marketing Mars Mastercard Meetings Mentoring Mentorship meta Microsoft military Mission Statement Mojave Mojave Experiment Money Mortgage Motivation Mozilla MySpace NASE National Women's Business Administration Networking new lending program NFIB NFL office OfficeMax Old Navy Olympia Snowe Olympics open source optimism index Organization P2P lending Packetel paperless partnership Payment payroll payroll tax Persuasion Planning Podcaster Politics PR Pricing procurement Productivity Raising Capital Rate of Return Real Estate recession marketing referrals Republic Windows retail retirement retirement plan blog retirement plans retiring Risk ritz carlton Roadmap to 2020 Roth IRA Sales Sales advice Sandy K. Baruah SBIR SEAS security self-employment self-employment assistance self-employment tax self-promotion Selling Seth Godin Slate Small Biz Advice Small Business Administration Small Business Legislation Small Business Salon social networking solar panels Southwest Staples Starbucks Start-up Start-ups stimulus Structure Success Super Bowl swine flu T-Mobile T-MobileDream TALF Tax Reform Taxes TechCrunch Technology TechRepublic telecommuting the bailout The Big Money the economy The Economy The Entrepreneur's Lament The Great Rearranging the states TIN Twitter unemployment United Parcel Service UPS vacationing venture capital Visa Vista Vista Small Business Assurance Wal-Mart Web 2.0 Windows women entrepreneurs Work/Life Balance Yahoo Yahoo! young entrepreneurs Zune